Our Story

Knight Insurance Group has a rich and long history.  The roots of our company date back to 1859, when the Shawen Stieg & Whitaker Agency was incorporated in Toledo, Ohio.  At the time, the product sold was mainly fire insurance.  Think about the time frame—two years before the Civil War began.  The light bulb was twenty years away from being invented; the automobile, fifty years!

The agency survived two World Wars, a Great Depression and watched America land on the moon.  The 1980s brought the invention of the micro-computer, and a kid named Bill Gates took IBM by surprise with his company, Microsoft.  In 1992, the World Wide Web was born, changing forever the way we get information and communicate with each other.  The 2000s brought the advent of the internet, smart phones, and artificial intelligence.  And things are moving more rapidly than ever.

Through it all, we have always been focused on sound insurance advice, competitive prices, and great service.  It’s really a simple formula, and it’s worked for us for over 160 years.

 

How We Become the Agency of Choice

Our Culture

Values drive behavior. It’s a fundamental principle of human nature. We behave based upon what’s important to us. If we believe deeply in something, our behavior becomes passionate. If we are lukewarm on a value, we’ll behave inconsistently.

This principle about values drove us to spend some time defining our values, and from our values, what specific behaviors we expect from our team members. Values drive behaviors, and behaviors produce outcomes (VBO). Our VBO or Core Values Statement was created with guidance from Tim and Bryan Kight of Focus 3 Culture.

Our people strive every day to be your Agency of Choice. Our people value exceptional standards, enduring relationships, and have a relentless focus to serve our business and family clients.

Our Culture
We See Things Others Don't

Our Process

Through the Knight Vision process, we learn about your business and customize risk strategies that minimize risk and reduce costs.  Once those are in place, we dig even deeper to examine other costs affecting the profit margin of your business.

Our Process
Our People Strive To Be Your Agency of Choice

Our People

We have always been focused on sound insurance advice, competitive prices, and great service.  It’s really a simple formula, and it’s worked for us for over 160 years. 

Our People

Internship Experience

Curious what it’s like to intern with us? Hear firsthand how our internship program provides meaningful experience, mentorship, and growth opportunities. This intern testimonial offers insight into the real-world impact of joining our team.

Leadership

Bud Bonner

Chief Executive Officer

Greg Corbitt

Chief Sales Officer

John Gage

Chief Information Officer

Sam Hammons, III, ARM, CIC

President and Risk Consultant

Diane Keil-Hipp, Ph.D., CPRM

Chief Operations Officer

Ken Knight, CIC

Chairman of the Board

Personal Insurance

Grace Anderson

Account Manager

Tracy Barber, CPRM, CISR

Senior Account Manager

Michelle Crosley

Account Manager

Stephanie Ehman, CIC, CPRM, CISR, CPSR

Risk Consultant

Heather Gaisie, CISR

Retention Specialist

Dorian Harmon, CPRM, CISR

Senior Account Manager

Marlene Levengood

Team Leader

Linda Lopez, CISR

Senior Account Analyst

Monica Romstadt, CPRIA

Risk Consultant

Selena Stagnolia, CPRM, CISR

Risk Consultant

Carol Taylor, CPRM, CISR

Senior Account Manager

NaJiya Whitman

New Account Administrator

Business Insurance

Nicole Bowles

Event Coordinator, Marketing Assistant

Phil Bowles

Risk Consultant

Ron Carter, CPCU, AFSB, ARM

Bond Manager

Jane Crispen, CIC, CISR

Senior Account Manager

Rick Diegel

Account Executive

Nick Etter, TRIP

Account Manager

Mitchell Fink

Risk Consultant

Matt Fox

Risk Consultant

Anna Gehring, AINS

Account Manager

Crystal Gleason, CISR, AU

Assistant Account Manager

Becky Goodrich CIC, AIS, AINS

Senior Account Manager

Natalie Grieser

Risk Consultant

Allison Hammons, CIC, CPIW

Risk Consultant

Wendy Harris, CRIS

Account Manager

Aliya Knight

Accounting & HR Specialist

Michele Merritt, CIC, CISR

Marketing Leader

Natalie Messenger

Account Analyst

Holly Reif

Team Leader

Carl Richardson, CIC

Risk Consultant

Michelle Roberts

Account Manager

Evan Rosplohowski

Risk Consultant

Travis Spitnale

Risk and Surety Consultant

Del Vath

Resource Manager

Ross Villella

Account Analyst

Matt Werner, CIC

Risk Consultant

Administration

Michelle Bowe

Information Specialist

Tom Daniels

Director of Talent Management

Bridgett Purpich, CIC, CISR, CAB

Talent Development Leader

Brenda Robinson

Director of First Impressions

Lauren Roe

Digital Media Specialist

Career Opportunities

 We want only the best!  Yes, we like to have fun, but we work hard too.  If you want to be challenged, expected to build exceptional business skills and live the Golden-Platinum rule, take a look at our open positions!

Browse Career Opportunities

Annual Report

2023 Annual Report

It was a rebirth of our 164-year-old agency. As the first full year as an employee-owned company, 2023 was filled with feelings of building the agency anew.

READ REPORT

2023 Annual Report Video

Our annual report is also available in video format. Click the button below for a summary of the full report.

WATCH VIDEO